The Difference Between Doing an Exercise and Wanting to Do It

What music, movement, and creativity might teach us about brain injury recovery.

By Tony Falsone | Project TBI

Since my traumatic brain injury in February 2023, I've spent countless hours in rehabilitation. Physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, cognitive exercises, and enough appointments to make me wonder whether rehabilitation had become my new full-time job. I've worked with some remarkable professionals, and I've learned an enormous amount about how the brain works. But somewhere along the way, I began noticing something that deserves more attention.

There's a big difference between doing an exercise because someone tells you it's good for you and doing something because you actually want to do it.

I recently came across a 2024 study published in Scientific Reports that got me thinking about this. Researchers had 30 adults play a drum under different conditions. Sometimes they followed a prescribed beat. Other times they improvised, either with recorded music or alongside a live pianist who responded to their playing.

When participants improvised with the live musician, they moved more, showed greater muscle activation, and reported greater enjoyment and reward. Nobody needed to tell them to work harder. The experience itself seemed to encourage greater participation.

The study wasn't conducted with brain injury survivors, and it didn't measure neurological recovery. But it raises an interesting question: What happens when an exercise becomes something we genuinely enjoy doing?

More Than Just Movement

Consider playing guitar. You're coordinating your fingers, listening to the notes, anticipating the next chord, maintaining rhythm, and correcting mistakes as you go. Your brain is constantly making decisions while your hands are moving.

Painting involves a similar combination of functions. You're judging shapes, distances, and colors while coordinating your hands and eyes. Each brushstroke involves a decision, a movement, and feedback that guides what you do next.

Even jiu-jitsu provides an interesting example. Balance, coordination, spatial awareness, and split-second decisions all happen simultaneously. It's an extraordinary combination of physical and cognitive demands, although contact training and choking techniques make it potentially dangerous for someone with TBI. I'm talking about the underlying skills, not recommending the sport as rehabilitation.

What interests me is that these activities combine movement, attention, coordination, and decision-making. You're not simply repeating an action. You're constantly observing, adjusting, and learning.

And that brings us to something called BDNF.

The Brain's Learning Environment

BDNF stands for brain-derived neurotrophic factor. It's a protein that helps support neurons and the connections between them. It plays an important role in learning, memory, and neuroplasticity, the brain's ability to adapt through experience.

Research has shown that physical exercise can increase circulating BDNF, although responses vary. BDNF also plays a role in the biological processes involved in learning new motor skills.

That makes me curious about activities that combine physical movement with mental challenges. Could playing an instrument, creating art, or practicing coordinated movements offer benefits beyond those of a simple repetitive exercise?

Possibly. But we need to be careful here. The drumming study didn't measure BDNF, and we don't have evidence that these particular activities necessarily increase BDNF or accelerate recovery after TBI.

What we do know is that movement, practice, feedback, and learning are connected. The question is how we can use that knowledge to make rehabilitation more meaningful.

The Part We Sometimes Overlook

Before my injury, I spent more than twenty years working in technology, solving problems and making decisions. Afterward, I found myself struggling with activities that once required almost no thought.

It's a strange feeling to go from managing complicated situations to sitting across from someone asking you to remember a few words or complete an exercise that looks deceptively simple.

I understood why I was doing those things. That didn't always make me want to do them.

But give me something I'm interested in, whether it's writing, drawing, researching, or solving a problem, and my approach changes. I become curious. I experiment. I make mistakes and try again. I'm concentrating on what I want to accomplish rather than what I'm struggling to do.

That doesn't necessarily make the activity better therapy. But it makes me more willing to participate.

And participation matters.

I've noticed something similar through TBIBridge. Some of my most meaningful experiences have come from conversations with other survivors. Nobody is assigning exercises or measuring performance. We're sharing experiences, responding to one another, and learning together. The music study doesn't prove that peer support produces the same neurological effects, but it certainly makes me appreciate how much human interaction can influence engagement.

There's another reality we can't ignore. Enjoying an activity doesn't mean we have unlimited energy for it. I've become so absorbed in something that I didn't recognize how cognitively exhausted I was until afterward. For those of us managing fatigue, finding meaningful activities also means learning when to stop.

A Different Way to Think About Rehabilitation

I'm not suggesting we abandon traditional exercises or replace therapy with hobbies. Rehabilitation is complicated, and different activities target different abilities.

But perhaps we should spend more time connecting rehabilitation to the things people genuinely care about.

Someone working on hand coordination might enjoy playing guitar or painting. Someone practicing attention and planning might prefer cooking, gardening, or building something. With the right guidance, those interests could become opportunities to practice important skills.

We talk constantly about neuroplasticity and the importance of repetition. What I'm beginning to appreciate is that the person doing the repeating matters just as much as the exercise being repeated.

The research on music, movement, and BDNF gives us interesting reasons to explore that relationship further. We don't have all the answers, but I think we're asking some worthwhile questions.

Because maybe rehabilitation shouldn't be only about what we need to practice.

Maybe it should also be about what makes us want to keep practicing.

Research Behind This Article

Project TBI explores brain injury through lived experience, scientific research, and community conversations. This article is educational and is not intended to replace individualized medical or rehabilitation advice.

ProjectTBI.com | TBIBridge.org

Next
Next

Research Opportunity: NYU Langone Is Recruiting Participants With TBI